Friday, 14 June 2019

Le Mans: Jock's Jottings

Jox pre-race Jottings..


Doing “ Jottings” by remote control a mere 386 miles away back in UK is a bit of a challenge! However, working alongside the “away team” and using all the media stuff available has made life tolerable and actually rather intriguing. Even so there may be errors!

Yesterday’s qualifying didn’t really throw up many major frights unless of course you were Rebellion who while they were bang on the pace, they were using up engines at an alarming rate. Both cars munched up an engine under what looked like very similar circumstances. Luckily between them Rebellion and Gibson naturally (?!) had a few spare engines “ in the back of the van” as Bart Hayden put it. The team will now be very slick if any more engines need swapping. We are not sure if they eventually had to run one of the race engines.

While we are not huge fans of BOP etc. it does seem that the non-hybrid LMP1 cars (SMP Racing and Rebellion) might at least now get a glimpse of the Toyota’s rear lights at some point during the 24 hours.  The jury is out as to whether Toyota was doing just enough to occupy the front row of the grid or maybe having to break into a modest sweat Their PR machine is so slick it is always hard to tell. This maybe Bykolles last year at Le Mans but contrary to their usual form they didn’t catch fire or fall apart.  In LMP2 Graff had been very cool and effective and took pole until the nice people at The FIA took away their lap times from the start of the session up until the time of the “ infraction” at 23:37 hrs. This was due to a transgression, clearly of huge magnitude, when their driver failed to stop at the weighbridge. This put them back to 14th. Seemed a bit harsh but “Rules is Rules” (certainly here at Le Mans!). Elsewhere Oreca had the edge over Ligier. TDS Racing #28 took pole ahead of Dragonspeed and Signatech. The best Ligier was #22 United Autosports car that was 6th on the LMP2 grid

For us the best bits of racing have traditionally come from the LMGTE Pro and Am cars... and this year’s qualifying was no exception. Like or loathe Balance of Performance The FIA seems to have got this about right. With Aston Martin, Ford, Chevrolet, Porsche and BMW occupying the first five slots on their grid in LMGTE Pro. This won’t have pleased Ferrari who was 8th with #71 AF Corse Ferrari 488 GTE Evo.  Who knows their BOP might be tweaked before the race. We have always admired the Corvette Racing lads. They seem ridiculously laid back and as usual, arrived at Le Mans short of relevant testing time.  However, as usual, they worked at their own, seemingly relaxed, pace and by the end of qualifying, they had eased #63 car into 3rd in LMGTE pro. Maybe the happiest team was Aston Martin who took pole ahead of #67 Chip Ganassi Ford GT. This was a great result for #85 Aston Martin Vantage AMR because Aston Martin is celebrating the 60th Anniversary of their famous win in the 1959 race.

When you see a BMW M8 being manhandled onto a low loader you can’t fail to notice what a huge car it is! So it was great effort threading #81 MTEK BMW M8 through the traffic to a respectable 6th
in class.

In LMGTE Am it will be another straight fight between Porsche and Ferrari . The #88 Dempsey Proton Porsche taking pole with the #84 Ferrari 488 GTE getting in amongst the impressive fleet of 911 RSR! Sadly one Le Mans regular the famous lurid green #99 Porsche 911 RSR will not be making the start. During practice Tracy Krohn had a major “off” which resulted in him winding up in hospital. He was not seriously injured but the FIA medical team decided he was not fit enough to race. It was a big hit but even so the Dempsey Proton engineers used a fresh chassis and the car was ready to race. The unlucky Tracy was not! The car has been withdrawn.

Any other business.


The whole Hypercar saga has been so fragmented that it is very hard to follow where we have got to. This year at Le Mans some meat is getting onto the bone. The ACO and FIA don’t seem to have gone into this with the major manufacturers behind them. The ACO have at last come up with a set of regulations. Any plans to develop a GTE ‘Plus’ and ‘DPi’ seem to have been shelved. Some of the basic regulations have been announced. First of which is a weight of 1100kgs with a maximum of 950bhp from a combination of internal combustion engine and hybrid. The maximum for combustion engine would be 508 kW and the hybrid bit supplying 200 kW.. Without doing any research this doesn’t look as if it will mean the Hypercars will be any quicker than the existing LMP2 machines. So they may not be the top level, outright race winners which is of course what the manufacturers need to justify the costs. Originally they were seen and being an LMP1 alternative.

Hybrids will be allowed which should meet the manufacturers need to appear “eco-friendly”. Since so-called Prototypes and Road cars will be racing together BOP will be a major feature. It seems “Aero” will be free. There will be a single tyre supplier. ( Maybe why Goodyear have entered the ring?)  Manufacturers will have to produce at least 25 road going versions of the cars by year one and then 200 by the end of the second season. This might be open to abuse.. look at the Ford GT! The race cars must use the same internal combustion engines and ERS that can be found on the road cars.

Toyota will probably join in since their TS050 Hybrid will not race beyond next year.

Aston Martin seems to be getting their Valkyrie model shape and an example was at Le Mans this year. It is allegedly powered by a V12 6.5-liter engine ... that will sound good. They are aiming at having the car ready to race at Le Mans 2021. They say they will run two factory cars in WEC. Toyota currently has an open mind since they will run the current LMP1 car for one more season and they may go “ Hypercar”. Ford are getting frustrated by the constant movement of goal posts.

Slightly more left field are Glickenhaus who have just welcomed Aston Martin to the Hypercar Club. James Glickenhaus is a film director, producer and screenwriter and by all accounts not short of a few dollars. He also a serious car collector and racer. They have been approved as a low volume manufacturer. He has entered for the full WEC 2020 season. It looks like GM might be their engine
supplier. It looks like a serious proposition. We like his dream “ These cars might be able to drive to Le Mans from Turin, race for 24hrs and then, if there is enough left, drive to Paris for dinner”. That is ‘old school’ Le Mans ambitions !!

We see this hypercar route as being ferociously expensive and also having overtones of the Porsche and Mercedes GT1 machines from the past which didn’t last long, were hugely expensive and did plenty of harm to costs and grids.

With Toyota due to move on from LMP1 hybrids, having lost Audi, Porsche and Peugeot from LMP1 the ACO seem to be looking a bit desperate to fill the financial sponsorship revenue gaps this has left.

Goodyear / Dunlop “Goodyear has announced that it will re-enter European and International sportscar racing by developing a new range of tires for the FIA World Endurance Championship (WEC), including the Le Mans 24-hour race." We find this rather intriguing bearing in mind that Goodyear recently merged with Dunlop to form one of the largest tyre manufacturers in the world. So Goodyear and Dunlop racing are closely related so it seems strange that Goodyear intends to take on endurance racing through WEC leaving Dunlop to look after ELMS etc. We are not quite sure what happens when Dunlop shod LMP2 cars arrive at Le Mans and find themselves racing against the new whizzy upgraded WEC Goodyear shod teams! It might mean the Goodyear WEC teams could have a huge advantage over their ELMS chums. Dunlop has always reckoned it “ owned” Le Mans! Hence the iconic Dunlop bridge, Dunlop chicane, and Dunlop curves... will they be renamed thus ending a relationship with Le Mans that has lasted since 1923?

Goodyear has been developing a new range of tyres for Le Mans Prototypes for over a year (that we don’t seem to have seen in UK and Europe) at their innovation centers in Hanau (Germany) and Colmar-Berg (Luxembourg). The tyres will debut at the start of the 2019/2020 WEC season at Silverstone in August.

There is one glimmer of hope for us fans.. maybe the Goodyear Blimp will reappear over the circuit. They flew between 1925 and 2017 ( for blimp anoraks they began to move over to semi-rigid airships from 2014). 

Nice gesture by Phillipp Enge he has redesigned his helmet to match that of the late Roland Ratzenberger who sadly died at Imola 25 years ago.

For the first time in ten years there is an all-female team racing here this year. Manuela Gostner didn’t start racing until she was thirty. Away from the circuits, she competed internationally at both indoor and beach volleyball. This is Rahel Frey’s second time at the 24 Hours of Le Mans. Her car failed to finish in 2010. Since 2015 Michelle Gatting has been an instructor for Porsche, at their three-month “Porsche Winter Driving Experience". They will be driving Kessel Racing Hublot sponsored #83 Ferrari F488 GTE They are starting 60th

2019 Predictions.. as usual, total guesswork.. unless both Toyotas fall to bits we can't see them not being on the podium. If Rebellion have sorted out their engine problems they might just edge SMP Racing off the top spot.

LMP2 looks mighty close but maybe a TDS win. LMGTE Pro... interesting. The heart says it would be great for Aston Martin to win this year celebrating their 60th Anniversary win. Could a factory Ford do it in their last year as works team , maybe not? Don’t ignore the ever competitive Porsches.. they are quite used to winning. The dream would rather a mature Corvette pulling it off, you just can’t trust those Yanks!! LMGTE Am ... Porsche really ought to win this due to sheer force of numbers my money would be on Dempsey Proton who are a very slick operation now.

Jock Simpson

Le Mans: Thursday Qualifying

Qualifying Session 2 of 3.

Track temp 27.2C Air temp 20.6C

In the opening laps after the green flag at 7pm, under clear sky and sunshine, Toyota discovered some pace, with Kobayashi lapping in 3:15.497 in the #7 Toyota and 3:15.908 for Nakajima in #8 Toyota. At the same time the #11 SMP with Aleshin at the wheel, did a lap of 3:16.953 and Sarrazin in the sister car #17 SMP 3:17.437. 



At 7:20pm there was a spin for Laurent in #3 Rebellion at Dunlop he rejoined but it was not the end of his problems. Jani put in a flying lap of 3:19.748 in the #1 Rebellion, but at the same time, Laurent in the #3 Rebellion gave out heavy smoke then dropped oil around the circuit and came to rest just after Mulsanne corner. The clean-up brought out a Red Flag at 7:27pm.

During the Red Flag period, the #4 ByKolles was being worked on in pit garage, reported to have brake problems. The #99 Porsche was seen in pitlane but evidently Tracy Krohn will not drive after his accident on Wednesday and the car was withdrawn. 



The session restarted at 7:50pm after a 23 minute stoppage. Jani in #1 Rebellion did a time of 3:17.313 on his first flying lap after the restart, putting the car in 4th place overall behind the #11 SMP.

At 8:07 the #3 Rebellion was being pushed down the pitlane by pit crew and was swiftly back into pit garage for repairs. At 8:11pm Konopka the #49 ARC Bratislava Ligier went into gravel at Mulsanne corner but rejoined.



Spin for Vanthoor at Mulsanne corner in the #92 Porsche at 8:20pm brought a brief local yellow. A moment later Flohr in #54 Spirit of Race Ferrari had a similar exit in the same place. We suspected that maybe some residue from the oil from earlier could be catching drivers out.


Going into the final 30 minutes, there was activity in the #36 Signatech Alpine garage as the Gibson engine appeared to be worked on. At 8:31pm, Ben Keating in the Ford GT #85 was another visitor to the gravel at Mulsanne corner and rejoined. At 8:38pm the #70 Ferrari was given a 3 minute stop and hold penalty for constant abuse of track limits. 



At 8:50pm Christensen in the #92 Porsche went quickest in GTE Pro with a lap of 3:49.388. At the same time, Antonio Garcia in the #63 Corvette improved to 3:49.424 putting it 2nd in GTE Pro. At 8:53 Dillmann in the #4 ByKolles improved the time for the car by 2 seconds with a lap of 3:23.726, but remained 8th in LMP1. Bruni in #91 Porsche put in a lap of 3:49.921 in the closing minutes taking the car to 5th in GTE Pro from 7th.

At the chequered flag of qualifying session 2.



GTE Am: 1st #88 Proton Porsche 2nd #56 Team Project 1 Porsche 3rd #54 Spirit of race Ferrari 
GTE Pro: 1st #92 Porsche  3:49.388 2nd #63 Corvette 3rd #67 Ford GT  
LMP2: 1st #31 DragonSpeed 3:26.490 2nd #38 JCDC Racing 3rd #36 Signatech Alpine 
LMP1: 1st Toyota #7 3:15.497 2nd #8  Toyota  3rd #11 SMP_Racing.


Qualifying Session 3 of 3.

Track temp 22.8C Air temp 17.7C

In the break we learned that the #86 Gulf Porsche needed a gearbox change and aimed to be ready by end of the session.



The final qualifying session went green at 10pm on a dry track. There was a flurry of purple sectors and quickest lap times in the first 15 minutes. In their first flying laps there was a 3:16.159 for Orudzhev in SMP #17 and 3:16.858 for Vandoorne in sister car #11. At the same moment also 3:25.503 for Duval in TDS #28 quickest in LMP2. Sorensen in #95 Aston 3:48.000 quickest GTE Pro and Cairoli in #88 fastest in GTE Am 3:51.439.



Catsburg in BMW #81 went off into the gravel at Ford chicane bringing out a slow zone and a temporary halt to quick lap times. The car was craned out of the gravel and the track went green again at 10:16pm.

There was a Full Course Yellow at 10:29pm to replace the flexible bollards known as 'floppies' at the Indianapolis / Arnage complex. We went green again at 10:33pm.


At 10:39, Lamy in #98 Aston Martin got stuck in the gravel at the 1st chicane on the Mulsanne after (we suspect) being caught out by cold tyres after pitstop. Meanwhile, Senna in the Rebellion #1 was stopped at Arnage with engine failure and evidently oil left on track. A red flag was called at 10:40pm to recover the #95 and clean up the oil from #1. The track went green at 10:56pm. Shortly after the green flag, Menezes put in a lap of 3:16.404 in #3 Rebellion to put the car up to 4th overall.

Maldonado in #31 Dragonspeed stopped at Mulsanne corner at 11:03pm causing a local slow zone. He got going again and returned to pits. At 11:17 the #86 Porsche was back out as predicted after gearbox change with Preining at the wheel.


By 11:30pm, all drivers had now done their night laps. Hedman in #10 was the last to do so.

With 16 minutes remaining Garcia put in a lap of 3:48.830 to put the #63 Corvette 3rd quickest in GTE Pro. Five minutes later Preining in #86 Gulf Porsche moved up to third in GTE Am with a time of 3:51.944. At 11:50 there was an improvement for Christensen in #92 Porsche 3:49.196 6th fastest in GTE Pro.

At 11:51 Lapierre set a lap of 3:25.874 #36 Signatech Alpine at 11:51 4th fastest in LMP2. Meanwhile, a lap of 3:49.116 for Muller put the #68 Ford GT up to 6th in GTE Pro.

At the chequered flag:



In LMP1 the #7 Toyota Hybrid takes overall pole with #8 Toyota Hybrid 2nd and  #17 SMP_Racing in 3rd.
In LMP2 #39 Graff Racing on pole from #28 TDS Racing with #31 DragonSpeed in 3rd 
In GTE Pro #95 Aston Martin on pole from #67 Ford GT and #63 Corvette in 3rd.
In GTE Am #88 Dempsey Proton Porsche on pole from #77 Dempsey Proton Porsche with #86 Gulf Racing Porsche in 3rd.


Text: Dave Davies
Pictures: Kristof Vermeulen & JellyBaby.Media

Postscript: The LMP2 pole-sitting #39 Graff Oreca had all its times deleted for the 3rd session because Capillaire ignored the light on the weighbridge at pit entry. This will put them 14th in class on the grid on Saturday.



Thursday, 13 June 2019

Le Mans: Wednesday practice and qualifying

Free Practice.


Wednesday was an unsettled day of sunshine and showers but mostly showers. It looked very much like free practice and the first qualifying session might be a wash-out. The practice session kicked off at 4pm on a damp circuit with isolated showers of rain occasionally dampening random parts of the track. There was however a dry period approaching 5pm and the GTE Pro & Am fastest times were already quicker than test day.




At 5:06 pm the #28 TDS racing Oreca was reported as going slowly at the entry to Indianapolis (possible transmission problem) and that the Dempsey Proton Porsche #88 was stopped on the circuit. This caused the first Full Course Yellow of race week.

Shortly after the FCY Kobayashi in #7 Toyota went straight on into gravel at Mulsanne corner but recovered and returned to pits where the car was pushed immediately into the pit garage.



At 5:38pm a few spots of rain could be seen on pit straight. It seems there may also have been a cloudburst on the Mulsanne straight as Tracy Krohn on his out-lap in the Krohn liveried Dempsey Proton #99 had a spectacular impact with the barriers at the exit of the second chicane. This caused the session to be red-flagged to recover the car and clean up the circuit. Tracy Krohn was reported as "conscious and in good spirits, but is suffering some back pain".
He was been taken to hospital as a precautionary measure.



























The track went green again at 6.24 pm after a 45 minute delay. The session was not extended. There was heavy rain during the stoppage and the restart was on a wet circuit. Within 30 minutes the track was drying gain although we were still seeing tails of water from the cars in some areas. At 6:52 pm the sun was shining on pit straight and lap times were falling again. By 7:24 pm there were 51 cars on track and dry times being set, and at the chequered flag at 8pm the circuit appeared to be fully dry and ready for qualifying.

Qualifying 


The first qualifying session began promptly 9pm. There was light rain at Arnage reported for the first 5 minutes but had gone by the time cars were on a first flying lap.  




Within a few minutes, the #68 Ford GT returned to the pits to have its door closed properly. This seems to be a recurring problem for the Ford GT. A little later the #10 Dragonspeed BR was reported as stopped on the circuit at MP11, the entry of the first chicane on the Mulsanne straight. It appeared to get going again then stopped at MP16, the second chicane, reportedly with a gearbox full of neutrals. A full course yellow was called to recover the car. 




Just after the end of the FCY Oliver Gavin in the #64 Corvette experienced a front right tyre failure early in lap and had to nurse the car around the entire circuit at a snail's pace. He managed to get the car home but the process caused damage that required a lengthy repair.

Rebellion #3 was stopped in the gravel at MP16, the entry of the 2nd chicane bringing out a slow zone as we went into the second hour of qualifying.




At 11:15 there was a bizarre incident at the Ford Chicane. Gonzalez in the #31 Dragonspeed Oreca had a spin and was rolling slowly forward on the track as Conway approached he chicane in the #7 Toyota. Conway saw the yellow flags and slowed down but didn't see the #31. The Toyota was launched into the air over the nose of the #31.

Conway: "I didn't see the car... I tried to go right but it was too late"

There was a slow zone called to remove the debris and the track went green at 11:20 with 40 minutes remaining

At 11:31 pm Pla in #66 Ford GT was approaching the Ford Chicane when the car snapped sharply right and plunged into a tyre wall. From the in-car camera, it looked as if it had been hit from behind but we don't think another car was involved. A slow zone was called to recover the #66 from the gravel. Eventually the car was able to limp into pit lane.




The #7 had a relatively swift visit to the pit garage for a new nose and minor repairs. Lopez climbed in and was back on track for the closing minutes of the session. 




At the chequered flag, quickest in GTE Am was the #88 Dempsey Proton Porsche, 2nd #56 Team Project1 Porsche 3rd #77 Dempsey Proton. In GTE Pro, quickest was #67 Ford GT, 2nd #93 Porsche, 3rd #97 Aston Martin. In LMP2 1st #31 Dragonspeed, 2nd #36 Signatechc Alpine, 3rd #22 United Autosports. In LMP1 quickest was #7 Toyota Hybrid 2nd SMP Racing #17 3rd RebellionRacing #3




You can't read much into the first qualifying times. Teams appeared to be getting drivers' night laps sorted and set-ups tweaked. Grid position isn't a big factor in a 24-hour race but the honour of being on the front row at the start on Saturday is not inconsiderable and will be decided at midnight on Thursday at the chequered flag of the final qualifying session.




Postscript:
Rebellion #1 times deleted - Stewards descision #48 - "Incorrect declaration of a fuel flow meter"